(through 2022-23)
| Rank | Player | GP | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Johnny Bower | 592 | 359 |
| 2 | Gil Mayer | 689 | 350* |
| 3 | Marcel Paille | 765 | 349 |
| 4 | Harvey Bennett | 540 | 260 |
| 5 | Michael Leighton | 507 | 250 |
| 6 | Bobby Perreault | 512 | 248* |
| 7 | Frederic Cassivi | 500 | 232 |
| 8 | Mike McKenna | 477 | 231 |
| 9 | Gord Henry | 510 | 226 |
| 10 | Drew MacIntyre | 440 | 225 |
| 11 | Red Almas | 450 | 218 |
| 12 | Nick Damore | 464 | 211 |
| 13 | Dustin Tokarski | 399 | 205 |
| Yann Danis | 414 | 205 | |
| 15 | Neil Little | 419 | 203 |
| 16 | Jean-Francois Labbe | 420 | 202 |
| 17 | Ed Chadwick | 417 | 196 |
| 18 | Dustin Tokarski | 363 | 193 |
| 19 | Gordie Bell | 471 | 190 |
| 20 | Connie Dion | 350 | 181 |
Most Wins, Career – 359
Johnny Bower – Providence, Cleveland
Most Wins, Season — 48
Gerry Cheevers, Rochester (1964-65)
*Hershey was 9-6-0 in games using a Mayer/Perreault platoon in 1958-59; wins were not assigned to either goaltender